The
Rational Argumentator
Shining the Light on Energy
I refer to the various energy policies, legislation, and regulations that are currently on the table. While healthcare may represent 1/6 of the economy, energy is the economy, as energy usage and GDP go hand-in-hand. There are three major energy issues that require diligence: Cap-and-Trade, Climategate/Copenhagen, and Carbon Rulings.
Cap-and-Trade has been a news item, reaching its current pinnacle in July, when the House passed the Waxman-Markey Bill, under which US producers (primarily energy sources) would receive tradable permits to emit greenhouse gases. It aims to cut manmade emissions from the United States by 83% by 2050. Remember, energy use and GDP are intricately connected. Energy cuts will have an economic impact and reduce jobs. The Waxman-Markey Bill turned out to be unpopular once the public got wind of the significant costs. Those who voted for the bill were booed back at home. Now, the Senate is unenthusiastic about its own version of Cap-and-Trade. Many say it is "dead on arrival." If it comes up in the Senate at all, most are suggesting that it will be in late Spring 2010. I called Senator Bingaman's office, and the staff there could not give me a potential date. Instead, they said, we are "doing healthcare now." Senator Udall's office did not respond.
In the midst of the quiet on Cap-and-Trade, days before the start of the Copenhagen Climate Conference, e-mails were leaked from the Climate Research Unit -- an event now known as "Climategate." These e-mails bring the entire issue of "climate change" into question. One has to wonder, why would the scientists hide or adjust data if they were as convinced of the strength of their case as they claim to be? The e-mails show a blacklisting of dissenting opinions, manipulating of peer review, and avoidance of freedom of information requests. Despite this, the Copenhagen Climate Conference is going full-speed-ahead in the hope of coming away with a treaty that will change the world as we know it.
Hope springs eternal. While on his Asian tour, Obama acknowledged that the best one could hope for is a political agreement. He is going back to the Scandinavian region with the promise of an 83% cut in US greenhouse gas emissions -- about which WSJ says that they "are only possible when everyone knows they will not happen." If the goals of the Copenhagen Conference are achieved, America will be paying reparations for an imaginary climate debt accumulated while building the greatest economy of all time. There is little "hope" that China, India, and even the Gulf Arab States will comply, thus making Copenhagen just a massive fossil-fuel-burning, carbon-emitting dog-and-pony show.
With the above scenarios as accepted fact, the Environmental Protection Agency had to do something to give President Obama cover. On December 7 (the opening day of the Copenhagen Conference), it announced that greenhouse gases "threaten the public health and welfare of the American people." Using the Clean Air Act that was written decades ago and was never, as the author agrees, intended to apply to carbon, EPA has given Obama a meaningless piece of paper to wave around in Copenhagen. While many businesses have sided with cap-and-trade thinking, it will be less onerous than EPA regulations; it is widely agreed that the Clean Air Act is the wrong vehicle for the task. As Congress is in the midst of addressing the issue, the EPA's saber-rattling is typical administrative overreach, violating statutory authority. The ruling gives EPA's non-elected bureaucrats the ability to threaten businesses and recalcitrant Democrats -- making it clear that they had best toe the line. Meanwhile, the EPA decision will be tied up for years -- if not decades -- in the courts.
Whew! While energy is not dominating the news cycle, it is still charged up. During this Christmas season, hang your lights, cook your feast, and stay warm inside! If each of these issues moves forward without a push back, it may be your last year to do so.
Marita Noon is the Executive Director at CARE (Citizens' Alliance for Responsible Energy), the nonprofit organization working to educate the public and influence policy makers regarding energy and its role in freedom and the American way of life. Find out more at www.responsiblenergy.org.
This TRA feature has been edited in accordance with TRA's Statement of Policy.Click here to return to TRA's Issue CCXXV Index.
Learn about Mr. Stolyarov's novel, Eden against the Colossus, here.Read Mr. Stolyarov's comprehensive treatise, A Rational Cosmology, explicating such terms as the universe, matter, space, time, sound, light, life, consciousness, and volition, here.